• Contact
  • My Account
  • Log In
  • 0Shopping Cart
thoughtLEADERS, LLC: Leadership Training for the Real World
  • About
  • Services
  • eLearning
  • Team
  • Blog
  • Clients
  • Books
  • Contact
  • Menu Menu

Build your skills! Take our eLearning courses on TITAN!

World-class eLearning courses with videos, exercises, downloads, and a certificate of completion. Get started today!

Structured Thought: Problem Solving
Structured Thought and Communication
Strategic Business Planning
Principles of Chart Design eLearning Course
Engagement Management
Deliberate Decision Making
Breakthrough Innovation
Everything is Negotiable
Leading through Change
Storytelling for Leaders
Storytelling for Salespeople
Building Leadership Resilience
Compelling Executive Presence
Coaching for Impact
Building Personal Resilience
Building Personal Resilience
Wide Banner SPS
Wide Banner STC
Wide Banner SBP
Wide Banner PCD
Wide Banner ENM
Wide Banner DDM
Wide Banner BTI
Wide Banner EIN
Wide Banner LTC
Wide Banner SFL
Wide Banner SFS
Wide Banner BLR
Wide Banner CEP
Wide Banner CFI
Wide Banner BPR
Wide Banner TMM
previous arrow
next arrow

Dealing with Tough Ethical Dilemmas

March 11, 2019/5 Comments/in Books, Guest Blogger, Leadership /by Ryan Shaw

Team Ethics Presentation

Ethical dilemmas can be tough to resolve, especially in today’s complex business environment.  Gut feeling and common sense are unreliable guides to ethical decision making. Only well-grounded ethical reasoning can lead us to the right choices and give us conceptual equipment to defend them.

Today’s post is by John Hooker, author of Taking Ethics Seriously (CLICK HERE to get your copy).

In June 2005, The New York Times published the tragic story of a young man who died of cardiac arrest while on a cycling trip. An implanted defibrillator should have restarted his heart, but it failed. The manufacturer, Guidant Corporation (now part of Boston Scientific), had known for some time about a defect that could on rare occasion cause the defibrillator to malfunction. It promptly fixed the problem when it surfaced but didn’t notify patients in whom the defective devices were implanted. The young man’s doctors were distressed and outraged when they learned about this. They insisted that they would have replaced the defibrillator if only they had known.

It gets worse. Guidant was considering a buyout offer from Johnson & Johnson at the time. Public knowledge of the defect would have led J&J to reduce its offer, which is exactly what happened when the story broke. It appeared that Guidant was keeping the defect a secret, and endangering the lives of thousands of heart patients, to protect its business interests.[1]

Yet the company’s behavior was entirely ethical. Why? I will explain in a moment, but the story illustrates how hard ethics can be, in two senses. The right decision can be hard to identify, and equally hard to defend and implement when it looks wrong to others.

We often have the impression that companies go astray ethically because of bad people. Sensational media stories about the Bernie Madoff’s and Martin Shkreli’s of the world reinforce this impression. Sure, there are bad people out there, but as often as not, ethical lapses occur when good people don’t know how to analyze complex issues. Even when there are bad people around, we often lack the vocabulary and concepts to identify why they are wrong.

The business world is awash in perplexing dilemmas. What is a fair price for a successful drug, given the high cost of research and clinical trials? Can a social media platform ethically sell personal data? When should it take down offensive or false material? Can a bakery ethically refuse to cater a gay wedding? Is it OK for a manufacturer to destroy a local economy by moving its operations to a low-wage country?

Resolving such dilemmas requires a sophisticated conceptual framework, not intuition or gut feeling. Fortunately, ethicists have worked hard to develop such a framework. I will give you a glimpse at how it applies to Guidant’s dilemma, although a truly convincing analysis requires a longer and more careful treatment.

This might have been a simple case, but for one fact: the risk of death from replacing a defective defibrillator (0.42%) was greater than the risk of leaving it in place (0.10-0.24%). Guidant executives feared that most patients would want a replacement if they knew of the defect, exposing themselves to unnecessary risk, and that most physicians would agree to do it (think about the cyclist’s doctors). The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) requires no product recall of implantable devices for precisely this reason. The company therefore reported the defect to the FDA but not to the public.

The conflict of interest posed by the prospective buyout did not arise until after Guidant made its decision. In any case, what matters is whether it was the right decision, with or without a conflict of interest. I will address this question by applying three well-known ethical tests. A decision must pass all three tests to be ethical.

The first test is utilitarian. It asks whether an action creates at least as much net expected benefit as any alternative action. Guidant clearly passed this test, because it minimized risk to 14,000 patients with implanted defibrillators.

The second test is based on a generalization principle that, in this context, asks whether a failure to recall is a breach of warranty. A sales transaction normally implies that the merchandise is fit for the purpose for which it is sold (warranty of merchantability). If a product is not usable, as for example when it is too unsafe to use, the seller has a legal and ethical obligation to notify the buyer and provide a replacement or refund.

This was not Guidant’s situation. It is hard to find legal grounds for recall, given that regulations make an explicit exception for implants. Furthermore, Guidant’s implantable defibrillators were the first on the market, and some risk is to be expected of new technology. It is unlikely that patients would have refused the implant if they had known, up front, that there was a 0.2% chance of failure—particularly if a 0.42% chance of death is not a deterrent to replacement surgery! Merchantability is therefore not an issue.

The third test is whether patient autonomy is violated. Patients may insist that they have a right to know what is going on in their bodies. However, a right claim doesn’t prove anything. It is only a claim. Patients may want to know about any defects, but there is no obligation to give people what they want just because they want it. More convincingly, patients may argue that keeping them in the dark compromises their autonomy because it deprives them of the opportunity to decide their own fate. This resonates with common sense, but common sense notions about ethics are often wrong.

Careful analysis reveals that there is no violation of autonomy. Let’s suppose you have a Guidant defibrillator in your body, and I am a Guidant executive who decides not to tell you about the defect. I violate your autonomy if I interfere with an ethical course of action you deliberately choose. I am not interfering with your choice to be informed of a defect, because this is not your choice to make. You don’t have control over whether I inform you. You can choose to ask a doctor to replace the device if you learn about a defect, but I am not interfering with this choice, because you have not learned about any defects. I certainly violate your autonomy if I expose you to unnecessary risk that results in heart failure, because heart failure interferes with any action you might take. But this is exactly what I am not doing.

The moral of this story is that careful analysis is the only viable way to deal with tough ethical dilemmas. It can resolve them when gut feeling and intuition are clueless, or at best misleading. It can provide vocabulary and concepts for defending controversial decisions. It can even help us summon the courage to forge ahead with the right course of action.

[1] Guidant’s dilemma is described in Martin E. Sandbu and Jeisun Wen, “Dicing with death? A case study of Guidant Corporation’s implantable defibrillator business,” Wharton School, University of Pennsylvania, 2008. Reprinted in W. M. Hoffmann, R. E. Frederick and M. S., Schwartz, eds., Business Ethics: Readings and Cases in Corporate Morality, Wiley, 2014, 636-642.

John Hooker, author of Taking Ethics Seriously: Why Ethics Is An Essential Tool For The Modern Workplace (CLICK HERE to get your copy), is a T. Jerome Holleran Professor of Business Ethics and Social Responsibility, and Professor of Operations Research, at Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. He has published over 170 research articles, eight books, and five edited volumes on ethics, philosophy, operations research, and cross-cultural issues, including Business Ethics as Rational Choice and Working across Cultures. He is the founding editor-in-chief of the world’s only academic journal dedicated to teaching business ethics, and he developed the ethics program in the Tepper School of Business at Carnegie Mellon University.

Did you enjoy this post? If so, I highly encourage you to take about 30 seconds to become a regular subscriber to this blog. It’s free, fun, practical, and only a few emails a week (I promise!). SIGN UP HERE to get the thoughtLEADERS blog conveniently delivered right to your inbox!

https://www.thoughtleadersllc.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/logo.png 0 0 Ryan Shaw https://www.thoughtleadersllc.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/logo.png Ryan Shaw2019-03-11 08:00:412019-02-09 09:30:15Dealing with Tough Ethical Dilemmas
5 replies
  1. Jeremy Lambertsen
    Jeremy Lambertsen says:
    March 12, 2019 at 1:57 pm

    It is interesting to note that if they had told the recipients, the exact same tests could be used to argue that was the ethical thing to do. I won’t go into the detail, but think about it and you can form the same argument on the other side of the coin. You need a moral compass to navigate life, but its not as simple as applying a logic test.

    Reply
    • John Hooker
      John Hooker says:
      March 21, 2019 at 5:31 pm

      First, no one says that applying logical tests is simple. In fact, that is the point of the article, which gives a simplified analysis.

      As for this case, it is not true that notifying patients of the defect satisfies all the tests. It clearly fails the utilitarian test, for reasons explained in the article.

      Actually it is common for both an action and its opposite to satisfy all the ethical tests (although that doesn’t happen here). I can eat broccoli with dinner or not do so; both are ethical.

      Reply
    • John Hooker
      John Hooker says:
      March 21, 2019 at 5:39 pm

      First, no one says that applying the logical tests is simple. In fact, this is the point of the article, which provides a simplified analysis.

      It is not true that notifying patients of the defect passes all the ethical tests. It clearly fails the utilitarian test, for reasons explained in the article.

      Actually it is common for both an action and its opposite to pass all the tests (although not in this case). I can eat broccoli with dinner or not do so; both are ethical.

      Reply
  2. Manish
    Manish says:
    March 20, 2019 at 5:30 am

    If the company continued to sell the defective pieces, that would have been unethical right? They are interfering with the choice of people to choose an alternative, or delay their choice until something better is available. Nice argument though.

    Reply
    • John Hooker
      John Hooker says:
      March 21, 2019 at 5:34 pm

      Right. Actually, Guidant corrected the defect as soon as it was discovered and sold only nondefective implants from there out.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Get free blog posts by email NOW!

It’s the best 5 minutes a week you can spend on your development.

Subscribe HERE!


All Contacts

Get new posts FREE via RSS!
Follow thoughtLEADERS on LinkedInFollow thoughtLEADERS on twitter
This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.
 

Check Out Our Courses

Our courses teach immediately applicable skills that have real impact on your business. From leadership to strategy and negotiation to conflict resolution, we have a broad set of course offerings that will drive immediate performance improvements.
OUR COURSES

Our Courses

Group of Business People Meeting
Puzzle Pieces
Glasses Looking Over Cityscape
Doors on a Wall
Cog Wheels
Man Reading Book
Fishing hook in the sea
Microphone in Lecture Hall
Charts on Blue Background
Wristwatch
Exploding Light Bulb
Man on Summit of Mountain
Lightning Bolts
Man Painting the Word Change on a Wall
Construction Cranes
Plant Growing in a Hand
High Performance Gears
Men Shaking Hands Closeup
Influence Definition
Sailboat at Sunset
Hanging light bulbs with glowing one isolated on dark blue background
Wagon Wheel
Executive Communications
Structured Problem Solving
Creating Leadership Maxims
Leading inside the Box
Deliberate Decision Making
Simple Strategic Planning
Storytelling for Leaders
Storytelling for Sales
Executive Presence
Principles of Chart Design
Time Management Mastery
Breakthrough Innovation
Leadership Resilience
Conflict Resolution
Leading through Change
Project Management Reality
Coaching for Impact
High Performing Teams
Everything is Negotiable
Leading with Influence
Building Personal Resilience
thoughtLEADERSHIP
Engagement Management
previous arrow
next arrow
 

eLearning Courses on TITAN

Structured Thought: Problem Solving
Puzzle Pieces
Structured Thought: Problem Solving

Clearly define a problem, scope all issues related to the problem, generate potential solutions, then analyze and select the best solution by using time-tested critical thinking methods and tools.

VIEW COURSE
Structured Thought and Communication
Group of Business People Meeting
Structured Thought and Communication

Craft clear and compelling recommendations that resonate with stakeholders. Get your ideas approved by using a proven method for delivering executive-level communications.

VIEW COURSE
Principles of Chart Design
Different Types of Line and Bar Charts
Principles of Chart Design

Create well-designed presentation charts that get your message across quickly and clearly to drive your audience to action. From data charts to concept charts, these methods help make your point.

VIEW COURSE
Engagement Management
Wagon Wheel
Engagement Management

Whether you’re an internal or external consultant or a project leader, learn proven methods, techniques, and processes to effectively lead consulting engagements that drive your client’s success.

VIEW COURSE
Strategic Business Planning
Cog Wheels
Strategic Business Planning

Use a straightforward and effective strategic planning process that shows how to craft a clear, compelling plan for your organization - not just one time, but on an ongoing basis year after year.

VIEW COURSE
Deliberate Decision Making
Deliberate Decision Making
Deliberate Decision Making

Make better, faster, and more effective decisions. Apply simple yet powerful decision making tools to define decision authority, manage risk, increase accountability, and drive execution.

VIEW COURSE
Everything is Negotiable
Men Shaking Hands
Everything is Negotiable

Become a better negotiator in all situations – from day to day interactions to hammering out large deals. Build the skills required to get what you want and strengthen relationships while you do.

VIEW COURSE
Breakthrough Innovation
Exploding Lightbulb
Breakthrough Innovation

Generate and select unique strategies that separate you from the competition. Construct bold and disruptive solutions then build and execute a plan for taking those strategies to market.

VIEW COURSE
Storytelling for Leaders
Man reading stories from a book
Storytelling for Leaders

Create business stories that inspire people, build connections with your audience, and ultimately advance your organization's goals by using a repeatable, straightforward method.

VIEW COURSE
Storytelling for Salespeople
Storytelling for Salespeople
Storytelling for Salespeople

Create and deliver stories that will take your sales efforts to the next level. Connect with and convince buyers in all situations using memorable stories. These stronger relationships drive more sales.

VIEW COURSE
Leading through Change
Leading through Change
Leading through Change

Lead your organization through the most challenging times using a proven change management process. Get people through the change and back to driving performance quickly and effectively.

VIEW COURSE
Building Leadership Resilience
Mountain Climbing Expedition
Building Leadership Resilience

Prepare your body and brain to be ready for and recover from your biggest challenges. Build approaches for overcoming stress, managing reactions to difficult events, and leading more effectively.

VIEW COURSE
Compelling Executive Presence
Compelling Executive Presence
Compelling Executive Presence

Build your ability to connect with your audience and convey your ideas in a clear and resonant way. Create meaningful connections between you and your audience to build buy-in.

VIEW COURSE
Coaching for Impact
Plant Growing in a Hand
Coaching for Impact: Foundation Course

Coach employees for performance and development more effectively by helping them identify and pursue their own solutions. Create the right environment and conditions to help them grow.

VIEW COURSE
Building Personal Resilience
Boat at Sunset
Building Personal Resilience

Build the habits and learn the behaviors required to manage stress, deal with adversity, and maintain your physical and mental wellbeing. Personal resilience is a key to your ongoing success.

VIEW COURSE
Time Management Mastery
Watches
Time Management Mastery

Learn techniques to manage your time, delegate, say “no,” and be more efficient. Balance your limited supply of time with the overwhelming demands that are placed on you every day.

VIEW COURSE
previous arrow
next arrow

Books You MUST Read

The Elegant Pitch
One Piece of Paper by Mike Figliuolo
Lead Inside the Box
10 Stories Great Leaders Tell
Getting Ahead
Sell with a Story
Lead with a Story
Mastering Communication at Work
The Hook
Innovative Leadership Fieldbook
Innovative Leaders Guide to Transforming Organizations
The Three Commitments of Leadership
The Littlest Green Beret
Storytelling in the Land of Oz
The Camino Way
The Leader with a Thousand Faces
The Inner Matrix book
The Vision Code
The Most Unlikely Leader
The Leader with a Thousand Faces
The Elegant Pitch
One Piece of Paper by Mike Figliuolo
Lead Inside the Box
10 Stories Great Leaders Tell
Getting Ahead
Sell with a Story - Border
Lead with a Story
Leading from Your Best Self
Mastering Communication at Work
The Hook
Innovative Leadership Fieldbook
Innovative Leaders Guide to Transforming Organizations
20120318 Three Commitments
Leadership Vertigo
The Littlest Green Beret
Storytelling in the Land of Oz
The Camino Way
Hijacked by Your Brain
Outthink the Competition
Driving Innovation from Within
The Voice of the Underdog
The Inner Matrix
The Vision Code
The Most Unlikely Leader
The Leader with a Thousand Faces
previous arrow
next arrow
  • The Elegant Pitch
  • The Vision Code
  • The Inner Matrix
  • The Most Unlikely Leader
  • The Leader with a Thousand Faces
  • The Voice of the Underdog

Categories

This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.

Our Course Offerings

Leadership Skills

Creating Your Leadership Maxims
Leading Inside the Box
Leading With Influence
Leading Through Change
Structured Problem Solving
Deliberate Decision Making
High Performing Teams
Simplified Strategic Planning
Strategic Business Planning
Coaching for Impact: Foundations
Coaching for Impact: Applications
Building Leadership Resilience
Engagement Management
Project Management Reality

Communication Skills

Communications: Foundations
Communications: Applications
Principles of Chart Design
Strategic Client Engagement
Storytelling for Leaders
Storytelling for Salespeople
Compelling Executive Presence
Advanced Facilitation Skills

Individual Skills

Conflict Resolution
Everything is Negotiable
thoughtLEADERSHIP: Innovation
Building Personal Resilience
Time Management Mastery

Coaching & Consulting

©2023 thoughtLEADERS, LLC: Leadership Training for the Real World. thoughtLEADERS, LLC is a registered trademark of thoughtLEADERS, LLC.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Cookie Policy
How often do you overcommit and stretch yourself too thin? Lessons in Leadership from CEO’s to the White House
Scroll to top